Shearwater - Fellow Travelers

Covers that lose the appeal of the originals…
Shearwater - Fellow Travelers

With Shearwater singer Jonathan Meiburg comparing this covers album to “leafing through a scrapbook” of touring experiences, you’d expect it to be a nostalgic, emotive offering.

But despite lending his rich, soulful vocals to an eclectic collection of tracks, including versions of songs originally by Coldplay and Wye Oak, the streamlined, country-tinged production waters the songs down.

Although David Thomas Broughton’s ‘Ambiguity’ is beautifully intimate, the urgency of Xiu Xiu’s ‘I Luv The Valley Oh’ (video below) and quiet/loud dynamics of St. Vincent’s ‘Cheerleader’ get lost in sweeping guitar riffs.

The fact that it makes you want to listen to the originals suggests Meiburg has more of a connection with his own innovative tracks.

6/10

Words: James Evans

- - -

- - -

The new issue of Clash magazine is out now and looks like this

Listen to ‘Fellow Travelers’ in full via Deezer, below…

Have your say

Sign in or Register to leave comments
-